US federal judge and Florida judge clash over Scientology wrongful death case

October 10, 2010

A United States federal court judge and Florida state court judge are enmeshed in a conflict against each other regarding a involving Scientology.

A federal judge for the, ,  Senior Circuit Judge Robert E. Beach not to intervene regarding appearance of an attorney in a  case involving Scientology. Lawyer Kennan Dandar is representing the estate of Kyle Thomas Brennan in a wrongful death claim against the Scientology organization.

The suit asserts that members of the Scientology organization, including the father of Brennan, removed access to the deceased's anti-depression medication, and provided him with means to utilize a loaded gun. Brennan had been staying with his father for a week prior to his death. Police in, Florida investigated the 2007 death of Brennan, and determined it was a. Kyle Brennan was himself not a member of Scientology. The lawsuit, filed in 2009, was filed by Brennan's mother on behalf of her son's estate. Named as defendants in the lawsuit include the Scientology organization, its subdivision the Flag Service Organization, twin sister of Scientology leader – Denise Gentile, and her husband Gerald Gentile.

Attorney Dandar had previously represented the estate of in a separate civil wrongful death claim against the Scientology organization. After being under the care of members of the Scientology organization for 17 days, McPherson died in Clearwater in 1995. The wrongful death suit claimed that Scientology officials permitted McPherson to deteriorate to a, where her condition was such that she did not have the energy to fend off from biting her skin.

Scientology management settled the McPherson wrongful death case in 2004; lawyers representing the organization stated the included a confidential arrangement with Dandar to never again represent clients in lawsuits against Scientology entities. The settlement included an agreement that both sides would never speak again about the case; California lawyer commented, "The church bought silence." The Scientology organization had also filed a countersuit against the estate of Lisa McPherson, and named Dandar a party to that lawsuit. The organization claimed Dandar had inappropriately tried to add the head of Scientology as a party to the wrongful death lawsuit.

Scientology legal representatives requested Judge Beach to see to it that Dandar abide by the secret settlement agreement, and Beach subsequently issued an order in June 2009 that Dandar be removed from the Brennan wrongful death case. Dandar faced sanctions from Judge Beach including suspension of Dandar's license to practice law, a 130,000 judgement to be given to the Scientology organization, and a fine of $1,000 per day. Judge Beach ruled that all money from the sanctions imposed against Dandar – were to go directly to the Scientology organization. The Tampa Tribune noted that Judge Breach made his ruling, "in an inexplicably closed hearing from which Beach tossed a St. Petersburg Times reporter".

Faced with these possible sanctions, Dandar filed an "involuntary" motion to withdraw from the Brennan wrongful death case in federal court, but Judge Merryday denied this request. Dandar stated to , "I'm stuck in the middle of two courts."

D. Wallace Pope, a lawyer for the Scientology organization, stated that he wished to show evidence regarding the settlement in the McPherson wrongful death case. However, Judge Merryday emphasized his main issue was determining whether or not Dandar was being penalized for obeying the federal court's order denying his request to be withdrawn from the Brennan wrongful death case. Judge Merryday stated he would prevent the Scientology organization along with Judge Beach from punishing Dandar for representing his client in US federal court. Merryday stated Beach had attempted to usurp control outside of his jurisdiction, thereby "aggressively" interferring with the US federal court process through imposing sanctions on Dandar.

Merryday has served as a US federal judge based in, Florida since 1992. The  noted that Judge Merryday, "has presided over some of the region's most noteworthy cases." Judge Merryday's court order creating an injunction against Beach was 29-pages long, and criticized the "stunning severity" of Beach's sanctions imposed on Dandar. Merryday explained that the federal court needed to "act in defense of the (federal) court's jurisdiction", due to Beach's actions. Referencing Judge Beach, Merryday wrote in his court order, "A judge should not undertake, directly or indirectly, overtly or through a surrogate, to compel an act by another judge, especially in a different jurisdiction."

Judge Merryday stated to Scientology lawyers, "have forced my hand on this issue." Merryday stated to Scientology lawyer, Robert Potter, "I don't like being put in this position. When people start to squeeze, other people can squeeze back." Potter asked him to seal the proceedings from public view, and Judge Merryday responded, "I'm not going to be entering any seals unless I see a lawful reason, and I can't even see the beginning of a reason". Merryday stated he would not allow his court to be influenced by "some circuit judge somewhere who appears for all I can tell to have sealed something for some unknown reason".

Judge Beach responded to Judge Merryday's which "permanently enjoined" him from imposing sanctions on Dandar, by filing a motion on Thursday in federal court in Tampa. Beach asked Merryday to rescind his order so that he may himself from acting as a judge on the Scientology case related to Dandar. Beach's motion argued that he was denied due process because he was not given notice by Merryday of the hearing which occurred before Merryday issued his ruling. In addition, Beach asserted Merryday did not have power to issue the ruling restricting him from sanctioning Dandar, because Beach was not a party to the Brennan wrongful death case, and Merryday lacked authority to restrict powers of a judge from outside his federal court jurisdiction. In response, Judge Merryday has scheduled a hearing for October 12 in federal court to hear state court judge Beach.

Martin Errorl Rice is an attorney in, Florida who represented Beach in the motion before the US federal court. Rice stated his client's motivation in requesting the ruling by Judge Merryday be rescinded was to allow Beach to recuse from the Scientology case. Rice told the St. Petersburg Times that his client's conflict with the US federal court has "cast kind of a cloud" over Beach's position in the Scientology case.

professor Michael Allen analyzed the clash between the US judge and Florida judge for The Tampa Tribune. Allen observed that it was "very, very rare" for a US federal judge to order a state judge. He noted that a contravenes such orders – except in "extraordinarily narrow" cases where the federal judges are permitted to create rulings in order to safeguard the jurisdiction of their federal court proceedings.